Compare and contrast between those winter sundays and my papas waltz

Order Assignment This order has already been completed on Studybay On Studybay you can order your academic assignment from one of our professional writers. Hire your writer directly, without overpaying for agencies and affiliates! Check price for your assignment 18 total offers received. Giftedhands94 Poems about fathers words Poems about Fathers Status:

Compare and contrast between those winter sundays and my papas waltz

Those Winter Sundays - Essay

To most people a father is not just the man who fertilizestheir mother's egg, but a man that spends time with and takes care of them. While doing this, he gains their love and respect. In these two poemsRoethke and Hayden take an admiring look back at the actions of theirfathers, although; they both imply that their parents were not perfect.

In this, what seems to be regular, occurrence his drunken fathercomes home for the night reeking of alcohol and begins dancing with him.

Compare and contrast between those winter sundays and my papas waltz

Roethke describes his father's hands as being battered on one knuckle andextremely soiled. They 'romped until the pans slid from the kitchen shelf'; This made his mother so upset that she could do nothing but frown. Finally, his father 'waltzed'; him on to bed.

In 'Those Winter Sundays'; by Robert Hayden, the poet alsorelinquishes on a regular occurrence in his childhood. On Sunday mornings, just as any other morning, his father rises early and puts on his clothes in thecold darkness.

He then goes out in the cold and splits fire wood with whichhe uses to start a fire in the house After the entire house is warm he calls therest of his family out of bed.

He does not get any thanks for doing this, butthat does not seem to matter. In both poems the poets seem to look back on their childhoods withmuch love and respect for their fathers. In 'My Papa's Waltz'; the titlesuggests a sense of love and honor.


Usually when a child calls his fatherPapa they have a very close relationship in which the child respects andadmires his father. Also, the use of the word Waltz suggests a Happy danceof high class people.

This is ironic because Roethke's father is drunken anddirty when this dance takes place, but when one thinks of the waltz they thinkof a dance between two high-classed people in an extravagant ballroom. Another example of the child's love and respect for his father is illustrated inthe things he overlooks just to be able to carryout the dance.

Although 'Thewhiskey your [his father's] breath could make a small boy dizzy';thechild 'hung on like death'; 3. The speaker also overlooks the pain of his earscraping against a belt buckle at every missed step of his drunken father justto continue his 'waltz'.

Roethke also indirectly implies his respect for hisfather by stating that his hand is 'caked hard with dirt'; This isrepresentative of his father having had a hard day at work.

Robert Hayden uses a different approach to imply his love and respectfor his father. He uses an example of a regular occasion that he did not paymuch attention to when he was a child but now that he is an adult he looksback on it with the utmost respect.

Just as any other day his father gets upbright and early on Sunday mornings. He puts on his clothes in the colddarkness and goes outside to split firewood. Although he does not pay thismuch attention in his childhood, Hayden really respects it as an adult.


Hisfathers actions are a result of his simple love for his children. Although hisapproach is different, Hayden uses one of the same references to his father asRoethke: Hayden refers to the condition of his father's hands withthis statement: This suggests that his father is a very hard worker.

Although both poems represent the poet's love and respect for theirfathers, there is one implement in each poem that suggests the fathers andfamily life was not perfect. The imperfection of the father in 'My Papa'sWaltz'; is clearly stated. He has a drinking problem. In relation to this themother's continuous frowning, the pans falling from the shelf may not havebeen the complete cause.

She could have been frowning because she is tiredof her husband coming home drunk every night.Comparison Analysis of “Papa’s Waltz” and “Those Winter Sundays” “Those Winter Sundays” by Robert Hayden and “My Papa’s Waltz” by Theodore Roethke both talks about father’s affection towards his son.

Whereas Hayden shows his regrets for not recognizing his fathers’ quiet but definite show of love towards him, Roethke.

Compare and contrast between those winter sundays and my papas waltz

Those Winter Sundays Robert Hayden, - Sundays too my father got up early and put his clothes on in the blueblack cold, then with cracked hands that ached from labor in the weekday weather made banked fires blaze. Robert Hayden’s poem entitled “Those Winter Sundays” and Theodore Roethke’s “My Papa’s Waltz” are depictions of fatherhood in two different concepts.

These two verses discussed how the father of the personas influenced their life and individuality. Assignment: Comparison/Contrast Essay Academic Essay. Choose two stories/poems/plays that we have read this semester to compare and contrast.

You might, for example choose texts that treat a similar theme. How does the plot, point of view, “Those Winter Sundays” Robert Hayden “My Papa’s Waltz” Theodore Roethke Love.

Jun 16,  · Theodore Roethke: "My Papa's Waltz" I often follow up Roethke’s poem with "Those Winter Sundays" by Robert Hayden and have them compare each speaker's tribute to his father.

I find that Hayden's poem helps them to understand the alternative interpretation to Roethke's because they begin to think about how a father displays his.

"Those Winter Sundays" by Robert Hayden is a poem about a how the author is recalling how his father would wake up early on Sundays, a day which is usually .

Paper 2, Comparing and Contrasting Poems